Casey and Cappie decide to tell people about their new relationship, and worry about how people may react. Ashleigh is excited but has her reservations since it took Cappie so long to realize what he wants with Casey. Evan doesn't seem to take the news of Cappie and Casey as well as he plays off, and OX playing a huge prank on the KTs adds to the problem. Casey talks Cappie and Evan into joining the KTs and OXs together for the ultimate prank – getting Officer Huck. They decide to drop Huck’s golf cart off a roof, but in the middle of the prank the OXs (including Evan) abandon the prank, leaving some of the KTs to take the heat which ends up being expulsion. The ZBZ girls prepare for Song Fest, which is their way back to the top of the Greek ladder. Katherine tells Beth she can’t take part since she deactivated to become an IKI, so ZBZ is down a girl and a choreographer - meaning they need a new dance entirely. Katherine also offers Casey a board position but tells her she can’t compete in Song Fest if she accepts the job. Casey decides to stick with her house, and the girls perform an amazing number yet strangely lose to the Gamma Psi’s mediocre performance. They realize something is off and sneak into the Gamma Psi house to find clues, but end up leaving a candle burning and setting the Gamma Psi house on fire! Rusty and Dale are still upset about fighting over the science grant they both want. When they gather to hear the final winner it‟s announced that, since it was such a close race, winners won’t be decided until next semester. Calvin talks them into trying to deal with their issues as tensions continue to rise. Rusty and Dale think it’s a great idea and decide the best way to do that is a Battle-Bot Royale! During the battle of their homemade robots Dale starts to lose. Calvin tries to get Rusty to realize that Dale needs this win more than him. Rusty has to make a decision to back down to be a best friend instead of the best competitor.

Directed by Michael Lang
Written by Roger Grant

Everyone is back from Winter Break, and the ZBZ girls are dealing with the guilt of possibly having burned down the Gamma Psi house. In hopes of helping them out, Casey volunteers to assist in planning a Fairytale Ball to raise money to rebuild their house. Cappie tries to be a great boyfriend by lending a hand but seems to keep disappointing Casey, causing her not to trust him enough to reveal her secret. When the fire department declares the fire was indeed caused by a candle left lit (one that Rebecca lit while they were inside) the girls freak out since Ashleigh still has the clipboard they snuck in to steal which is now evidence against them. They decide the best thing to do is bury the evidence – literally. In the meantime, Cappie is having a hard time getting over Wade, Jeremy and Ferret being expelled over the prank with OX. When Rusty tries to take over Wade’s position as pledge educator, Cappie doesn’t have his back as much as usual since he doesn’t think anyone will live up to the job Wade did in the past. While trying to tame the pledges, Rusty learns that he beat Dale (who had already hired interns!) out for the engineering grant which causes the tension between them to continue. Over at OX, Calvin is annoyed when he learns Grant didn’t come out to his parents over the break so they have to wait to come out to the house as a couple. Evan and Rebecca try to figure out how to proceed in their friendship after they hooked up before Winter Break.

Directed by Michael Lang
Written by Casey Johnson & David Windsor

Katherine offers Casey the Vice President of Judicial Affairs position and gives her the first task - investigate the fire that burnt down the Gamma Psi's house. ZBZ's are still on edge that they are going to get caught, and Casey can't handle the guilt so confesses to Natalie. When Natalie doesn't turn her in and instead she blackmails her in exchange for ZBZ's house, Casey digs deeper and finds evidence that Natalie rigged Songfest by sleeping with a judge. Casey exposes her own guilt and Natalie's deception to Katherine but at the price of losing Katherine's budding friendship and the VPJ position. Winning the Gary Wyatt grant has been great for Rusty's popularity - female engineers are hot for him, but the girls he wants (sorority girls) aren't fazed by his success. Ashley helps them both by having a nerd auction to raise money for the Gamma Psi's house rebuild. Ashleigh makes Rusty over to be nerd-chic, but in the end sorority girls still see Rusty as their own personal Geek Squad. In the process he blows off the cute engineering nerd (Dana) who has had a crush on him since orientation. When he realizes his mistake he asks her out, but Dana refuses. Evan and Cappie's tumultuous relationship comes to a head at the Amphora society where they are both expelled. Cappie and Casey cope with the fact that while Cappie and Evan's friendship is over, Casey and Evan are becoming friends and Rebecca and Cappie will be in a human sexuality class together.

Directed by John Kretchmer
Written by Jessica O'Toole & Amy Rardin

Casey and Ashleigh miss each other now that Casey spends most of her nights at Cappie's place. Casey's solution is for Ashleigh to start dating Beaver! On a terrible double date, the KT's extend Casey and Ashleigh an offer to play with ZBZ in the upcoming softball tournament for blue ribbon points. Ashleigh stalls to answer until the Omega Chi's extend an offer and the ZBZ's (minus Casey) whole heartedly accept. Since Gamma Psi assumed the Omega Chi was going to extend them an offer, they choose KT to ruffle the feathers of ZBZ. On the field, tensions are high, and come to a head when Grant freaks out because he's getting teased for coming out of the closet. Calvin tells him to let it go but Grant finds an unlikely supporter in Rusty who actually has his back in the argument that ensues. At the game winning pitch, Casey is forced to choose between her allegiance to ZBZ and Cappie, but her competitive side helps her choose ZBZ. Cappie is supportive but Casey sees that maneuvering this relationship may not be easy.

Written by Matt Whitney
Directed by Lee Rose